Is a Raw Diet Right for Your Dog?

Raw feeding for dogs has grown in popularity, with many owners attracted to the idea of “natural” food and glossy coats. Whether a raw diet is right for your dog depends on health, lifestyle, budget and how carefully the diet is planned. I

s a Raw Diet Right for Your Dog?

Dogs love a nutritonally balanced raw food

What is a raw diet?

Raw feeding usually means a diet based on uncooked animal products such as meat, organs and bones, sometimes combined with fruits, vegetables and supplements. Some owners prepare homemade raw diets, while others use commercially prepared frozen raw foods that are formulated and tested to be complete and balanced for dogs.

That last part is crucial. For most pet families, choosing a reputable commercial frozen raw brand that clearly states it meets recognised nutritional standards (for example “complete and balanced for adult dogs”) is the safest way to feed raw while covering all the vitamins, minerals and amino acids your dog needs. A scoop of raw mince and some veggies at home might look healthy, but it is very unlikely to be nutritionally complete without expert formulation.

Potential benefits

When properly formulated, raw diets can be high in protein and moisture and relatively low in processed carbohydrates. This may suit some dogs with specific digestive issues or food preferences. Many owners of dogs on well balanced commercial frozen raw diets report good stool quality, shiny coats and strong appetites.

Chewing appropriately sized raw meaty elements can also provide some dental cleaning effect for certain dogs, although this is not a replacement for tooth brushing or veterinary dental care. These benefits, however, depend heavily on the diet being correctly designed. A high quality commercial frozen raw food is far more likely to be balanced than a home assembled mix of meat and bones, because it is usually formulated with professional input and batch tested.

Why nutritional balance matters

Dogs require specific amounts of protein, fat, essential fatty acids, vitamins and minerals for each life stage. Getting this balance wrong, even with ingredients that look “fresh” and “natural”, can cause long term problems. Common issues seen with poorly designed homemade raw diets include:

- Too much or too little calcium and phosphorus, which can damage growing bones in puppies and affect bone health in adults.

- Deficiencies in trace minerals or vitamins that affect skin, coat, immune system and metabolism.

- Excess fat or too few calories, leading to pancreatitis or weight and muscle loss.

Commercial frozen raw foods from reputable brands are designed to avoid these mistakes. They formulate to recognised standards and aim to provide all essential nutrients in the right ratios, so you do not have to guess. Home prepared raw meals, unless designed by a veterinary nutrition professional and followed precisely, often miss the mark.

Risks and challenges of raw feeding

There are still important risks to consider with any raw diet:

• Bacterial contamination: Raw meat can carry pathogens such as Salmonella or Campylobacter, which may affect both dogs and people. Good commercial brands have strict hygiene controls and quality checks, while home kitchens usually do not.

• Bone hazards: Improperly selected bones can cause chipped teeth, blockages or constipation.

• Handling and storage: Raw food, whether commercial or homemade, needs careful storage, thawing and cleaning routines to be as safe as possible.

Using a commercial frozen raw product does not remove all of these risks, but it does allow more consistent quality control and clearer feeding guidelines than improvising at home.

When homemade raw might not be appropriate

Raw diets are generally not recommended for:

• Dogs with weakened immune systems or those on certain medications.

• Very young puppies unless under strict veterinary nutrition guidance.

• Households with young children, older adults or people with health issues who may be more vulnerable to food borne illness.

In these situations, if owners are still interested in raw feeding, a good commercial frozen raw diet and close veterinary supervision are much safer choices than experimenting with homemade recipes. Even then, your vet may advise a different style of diet if risk is high.

Working with your vet and groomer

Before moving to raw, especially if you plan to prepare food yourself, talk with your vet. For most dogs, your vet will recommend choosing a complete and balanced commercial food, whether that is a high quality cooked kibble or wet food, or a reputable commercial frozen raw product. If you are very keen on raw, a commercial frozen raw diet plus targeted advice from a veterinary nutrition professional is usually far safer than a DIY approach.

Your groomer can provide practical feedback on how diet appears to be affecting:

• Coat shine and texture.

• Shedding and matting.

• Skin condition and odour.

A good quality, balanced commercial diet (raw or cooked) often shows up as a coat that is easier to brush, with fewer mats and less dandruff. If a dog moves to a homemade raw plan and the coat becomes dull or the skin flares, that can be a sign that the diet is not balanced and needs review.

In the end, the “right” diet is one that keeps your dog healthy, comfortable and thriving. For families who like the idea of raw feeding, a well chosen commercial frozen raw food that is clearly labelled as complete and balanced is usually the safest and most reliable way to do it, rather than relying on guesswork in the kitchen.

Sources

[1] Ratio Pre-made VS Commercial Balanced raw Pet Food https://perfectlyrawsome.com/raw-feeding-knowledgebase/ratio-commercial-premade-pet-food-comparison/

[2] Properly Balancing Raw /Fresh Food - Commercial Brands https://www.doodledogsboutique.com/pages/properly-balancing-raw-fresh-food

[3] Raw Beef Dog Food - Complete & Balanced AAFCO Recipe https://rawandfresh.com.au/products/complete-beef-dog

[4] Most homemade dog diets lack nutrients, Texas A&M study finds https://stories.tamu.edu/news/2025/11/21/most-homemade-dog-diets-lack-nutrients-texas-am-study-finds/

[5] Homemade dog food diets lack essential nutrients, raising disease risk https://www.nutritioninsight.com/news/dog-food-pet-nutrition-kibble-veterinary.html

[6] 5 Dangerous Mistakes People Make When Raw Feeding Their Dog https://www.thecaninedietitian.co.uk/blog/5-dangerous-mistakes-people-make-when-raw-feeding-their-dog-and-how-to-fix-them

[7] UK dogs eating raw meat diets have higher risk of __Salmonella__ and antimicrobial‐resistant __Escherichia coli__ faecal carriage https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jsap.13488

[8] Occurrence of Salmonella, Campylobacter, Clostridium and Enterobacteriaceae in raw meat-based diets for dogs - PubMed https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30833301/

[9] The raw end of the deal: the risks of bacteria in raw pet food https://www.veterinary-practice.com/article/risks-bacteria-raw-pet-food

[10] Whole Dog Journal's Commercial Frozen Raw Dog Food ... https://www.whole-dog-journal.com/food/whole-dog-journals-commercial-frozen-raw-dog-food-review/

• On why “complete and balanced” commercial foods (including commercial frozen raw) are safer than DIY raw for covering all essential nutrients, and why labels should show which standard they meet (AAFCO or FEDIAF).[1][2][3]

• On the fact that most homemade dog diets may be nutritionally incomplete, with only about 6 percent meeting essential requirements, and that incorrect calcium and phosphorus balance can cause serious bone and kidney problems.[4][5]

• On common nutrient gaps and mistakes in unbalanced raw feeding (for example 80/10/10 style meals lacking key vitamins, minerals and fatty acids, and not meeting FEDIAF or NRC guidelines).[6][1]

• On bacterial risks of raw feeding, including higher carriage of Salmonella and antimicrobial resistant E. coli in raw fed dogs, and the need for strict hygiene when storing, handling and feeding raw meat based diets.[7][8][9]

• On how reputable commercial frozen raw foods are produced under controlled conditions with quality checks, ingredient standards and compositional testing, making them more reliable than ad hoc home mixtures.[2][3][10]

Disclaimer

The content, advice, products, and services provided on this blog are based on the professional experience of Masters Pet Grooming and its staff. All information is provided in good faith for general informational purposes only.

Any misuse, neglect of instructions, or intentional harm carried out by individuals - including failing to follow the directions of qualified professionals such as veterinarians, dieticians, physiotherapists, or other licensed practitioners - is considered unsafe, unwarranted, and strongly discouraged. Users are reminded to always follow the instructions of their professional care provider and comply with manufacturer guidelines when using any product or service.

To the maximum extent permitted by applicable Victorian and Australian law, Masters Pet Grooming, its staff, and its affiliates accept no liability for any injury, loss, or damage arising from:

• reliance on information provided on this blog without seeking appropriate professional advice;

• failure to follow directions from a qualified professional or manufacturer;

• any action taken that falls outside the scope of our guidance.

By using this blog, you acknowledge that professional judgment, as given by a licensed veterinarian, healthcare provider, or other qualified specialist, should always take precedence over general advice. Masters Pet Grooming and its affiliates expressly disclaim all liability for actions taken contrary to these directions.